Neurodivergent Approaches to Plot Structure: Letting Go of ‘The Rules

If you’ve ever stared at the three-act structure and thought, this doesn’t fit the story in my head, you’re not alone. Many neurodivergent writers—myself included—find that traditional plot structures can feel restrictive or even discouraging.

This post is for the writers who have been told their storytelling is “too weird,” “too scattered,” or “not structured enough.” If that rings a bell, maybe it’s time to explore narrative forms that fit you, not the other way around.

1. Recognizing that Structure is a Tool, Not a Law

Much like grammar, plot structure exists to serve your story—not to limit it. The three-act structure, Hero’s Journey, Save the Cat—these are useful tools, but they were designed within a neurotypical framework. If your brain doesn’t move in a straight line, why should your story?

The three acts is, inciting incident, midpoint, climax, resolution. While these blueprints can be helpful, they’re just one lens. They’re not a universal truth.

Neurodivergent writers often thrive in pattern-making, but not always in linear progression. Our brains might not process time, stakes, or cause and effect in “standard” order. That doesn’t mean we’re doing it wrong—it means we’re doing it differently.

🔗 Want a breakdown of alternative structures? Check out this guide by Reedsy on nonlinear narrative techniques.

Start by asking: What would happen if I used structure as a scaffold, not a cage? Let it serve your story, not dictate it.

2. Why Traditional Plot Structures Often Don’t Work for Neurodivergent Writers

Autistic and ADHD creators often perceive and process time, cause and effect, and emotional stakes differently.

There’s a reason neurodivergent creators often struggle with plotting: traditional arcs rely on assumed emotional pacing, attention spans, and priorities. But what if your story wants to be quiet? Or cyclical? Or fragmented?

Maybe your brain works in themes instead of events. Maybe you need to explore your world before you discover your character. Maybe your climax is internal instead of external. These are all valid.

Many of us also experience time nonlinearly—trauma, sensory processing, or hyperfocus can shape how we recall or describe events. A story that loops, spirals, or sidesteps might be the most honest version of the truth you want to tell.

That’s not a flaw—it’s a signature. Just like in neurodivergent masking, some of us unconsciously try to "mask" our creative instincts to match industry expectations.

3. Embracing Neurodivergent Structures

Try asking: What would this story look like if it unfolded how my brain naturally tells it? Maybe the climax happens early. Maybe there isn’t a climax. Maybe the story loops, spirals, digresses.

There are infinite ways to structure a story. Here are a few nontraditional frameworks that may resonate:

Spiral structure – revisiting the same themes or moments from different angles
Fragmented structure – chapters or sections that feel disconnected but build a mosaic of meaning
Looped narrative – the ending mirrors the beginning, or the story keeps cycling
Modular storytelling – each part stands alone but creates an emotional arc when read together

🔗 Sequoia Nagamatsu’s How High We Go in the Dark is a beautiful example of modular, nonlinear storytelling.

🔗 Carmen Maria Machado’s In the Dream House defies genre and format entirely—and it’s brilliant.

These approaches allow you to focus on resonance over resolution, meaning over mechanics.

4. Letting Go of Shame Around “Messy” Drafts

So many of us carry shame around how we write: too slow, too scattered, too inconsistent. But “messy” is often where magic lives.

Neurodivergent writing might not follow clean outlines or predictable pacing. You might write the ending before the middle. You might have ten tabs open and a sticky note storyboard that makes no sense to anyone but you. That’s okay. That’s real.

Your writing process doesn't need to look "productive" to be meaningful. You’re allowed to play, wander, and return. Embrace the nonlinear. Find comfort in the chaos.

🔗 I love this piece from Electric Literature on neurodivergent writing processes.

5. Neurodivergence Is a Storytelling Superpower

Our minds are wired for layered meaning, metaphor, nonlinear experience, emotional depth. That’s a gift. Your plot doesn’t have to mimic a Hollywood blockbuster to be valid or moving.

When you honor your way of thinking, you honor your reader too—especially the ones who see the world like you do.

Neurodivergent people often see connections others miss. We live in metaphor. We sit with ambiguity. We notice the small, strange details that build emotional truth. That is power—not a liability.

The world needs more stories that break the mold. More stories that follow rhythm over rules. If your story structure doesn’t make sense to everyone—maybe that’s the point. It might speak to the people who’ve never felt seen before.

Give yourself permission to tell stories the way you experience the world. That authenticity can’t be taught—it can only be trusted.

Writing Prompts for Your Neurodivergent Story Structure

Try these journaling or drafting prompts to explore your unique narrative style:

What does “beginning” mean in your story? Could it be a feeling, not a moment?
What would happen if you built your story like a memory, not a timeline?
How would this story unfold if told in vignettes or images instead of scenes?

There’s no wrong way to tell a story that’s yours.Further Reading & Resources

📘 “Unlearning the Hero’s Journey” — A reframe on story structure
📚 “The Chronology of Water” by Lidia Yuknavitch — Experimental memoir magic
💻 Plotter Not Required: Tools for Unconventional Writers — From Well-Storied

You don’t have to force your creativity to fit the mold. Sometimes the most powerful stories are the ones that wander, loop, and refuse to explain themselves. Especially when they’re true to you.

With ink-stained thoughts.

Search This Blog

Ink & Identity